Take Pity on Me

by Stacey

A new study released earlier this month shows that breastfeeding can raise intelligence by an average of nearly seven IQ points if the child has a particular version of a gene called FADS2. Thanks to this article in Slate for the tip. The study involved more than 3,000 children in Britain and New Zealand.

“There has been some criticism of earlier studies about breastfeeding and IQ that they didn’t control for socioeconomic status, or the mother’s IQ or other factors, but our findings take an end-run around those arguments by showing the physiological mechanism that accounts for the difference,” said Terrie Moffitt, a professor of psychological and brain sciences in Duke University’s Institute for Genome Sciences and Policy.

“The argument about intelligence has been about nature versus nurture for at least a century,” Moffitt said. “We’re finding that nature and nurture work together.”

Ninety percent of the children in the two study groups had at least one copy of the “C” version of FADS2, which yielded higher IQ if they were breast-fed. The other 10 percent, with only the “G” versions of the gene, showed no IQ advantage or disadvantage from breastfeeding.

The researchers focused on the gene because it produces an enzyme that helps convert dietary fatty acids into polyunsaturated fatty acids (DHA and AA) that have been been shown to accumulate in the human brain during the first months after birth.

Since the first findings about breastfeeding and IQ appeared a decade ago, many formula makers have added DHA and AA fatty acids to their products. The children in these studies however were born in 1972-73 in New Zealand and 1994-95 in England, before fatty acid supplementation in formula began.

It isn’t known for sure whether such supplementation has made a difference in humans, the release says, but lab studies in which rodents and primates were fed supplemental fatty acids have shown increased brain DHA concentrations and enhanced abilities in tests of learning, memory and problem-solving.

I could sit here and feel satisfied with a 90 percent chance of certainty that my breastfed kids will be brighter than they otherwise would have been, but frankly I’m too busy wallowing in self-pity. My mother didn’t breastfeed me. It was out of fashion at the time and she did what the doctors told her to do. I don’t blame her.

But think about it. With that boost, I could have been seven points smarter than I am! Seven points. Maybe I would be better at remembering people’s names after they introduce themselves to me. Or maybe my head wouldn’t spin quite as much when confronted with algebraic conundrums. Heck, I might even understand things like how batteries can make things go.

It’s sad really. I’m just glad I’ll be able to provide a better life for my kids. Isn’t that what I’m supposed to think?

Sphere: Related Content

6 Responses to “Take Pity on Me”

  1. dcslugabed Says:

    I’m with you, Stacey. While it’s interesting to see scientists tracking how to measure what’s good and bad for IQ, I have to wonder how much it really means. I’ve recently read that eating fish while pregnant raises the baby’s IQ, as does breastfeeding–they seem to be on to something about these fatty acids and brain growth– while apparently being the second born or later reduces IQ. I’m sure there are many of other factors swilling around. If someone does every single one of those things — eats fish, breastfeeds, etc. for their firstborn, will all those IQ points pile up until that baby becomes the smartest person ever? And I know there are studies out there linking IQ and success and happiness, but in my actual life, it seems to me that the people I know with the highest IQs are not necessarily the happiest or most successful. Related to another of your recent posts, the Washington Post had an article the other day about how having the flu while pregnant raises the risk that your child will get schizophrenia–and, as it is apparently due to the antibodies rather than the flue itself, having a flu shot may raise the risk of schizophrenia as well. Which basically dooms any woman with a toddler in the house who wants to get pregnant to that higher risk of schizophrenia in her child.

  2. Stacey Says:

    Right. I’m skeptical about this IQ research. And being super smart is over-rated anyway, like you said. Not that I would know.

    Here’s a link to that WaPo article. Thanks for mentioning it.

  3. Anna Says:

    And really, the number of women that have been sick with the flu while pregnant is probably pretty high… but is the number of children diagnosed with schizophrenia a similar number? I think not!

    Sometimes this research gets out of hand.
    It makes you question everything…
    Really, it makes me realize that we really know very little; but from what we do know, we create a lot of anxiety. Geesh!

  4. Sally Says:

    I don’t think anything would’ve helped me with algebra, frankly.

    Nice meeting you at Kenny and Mickey’s. I’m reading you daily, now.

  5. fussbucket Says:

    Great! Glad to have you with us Sally.

  6. CypeImmeleWal Says:

    Make love, not war!

Leave a Reply